Efforts to boost tax revenue will come to naught if expenses, particularly on ‘welfare schemes’, are allowed to grow in an unsustainable manner For years, the tax receipts of the Union Government have consistently fallen short of the target set in the respective year which together with the expenditure exceeding the target has led to fiscal slippage – a glamorous term for the fiscal deficit (FD). Against this dismal record in the past, 2021-22 will have the unique distinction of the tax collections – both direct and indirect – exceeding the target. The total direct tax collection net of refund as on March 16, 2022 stood at around Rs 1363,000 crore which is higher the budget estimate (BE) of Rs...
More Comments are closed
Articles
Time to revisit the three farm laws
When farmers get dozens of options to sell, plain common sense says that they are bound to get a good deal in every respect, including a good selling price While, staying the implementation of the three contentious farm laws, the Supreme Court (SC) had set up a Committee to recommend the way forward. The committee submitted its report on March 19, 2021. Even as the SC action on the report was pending, on November 19, 2021 Prime Minister Narendra Modi announced repeal of the laws even while maintaining that these laws are beneficial to small and marginal farmers who are in a majority. Now, in a startling revelation, Anil Ghanwat, a member of the committee has revealed that around 85.7...
More Comments are closed
Gas shock: India’s vulnerabilities
The Govt should maintain a reserve of gas equal to a percentage of annual use which can be used as buffer to meet demand at affordable price during crises The Ukraine war has exposed the vulnerabilities in India’s gas supply systems. Our demand for natural gas (NG) is around 54.6 billion cubic meter (bcm) of which nearly 50 percent is met from import as liquefied natural gas or LNG. Russia is the world’s second-largest producer of NG with a share of 10 percent. In total world export of gas, its contribution is even higher at 25 percent. Most of Russian gas goes to the European Union (EU) countries with the latter drawing 40 percent of their total NG supplies from...
More Comments are closed
Fertiliser subsidy: Political will missing
In the Union Budget for 2022-23, the Modi government has allocated Rs 1,05,000 crore for fertiliser subsidy, which is Rs 35,000 crore less than the revised estimate (RE) for 2021-22 at Rs 1,40,000 crore. Fertiliser subsidy arises because the Centre wants manufacturers/imports to sell fertilisers to farmers at a low maximum retail price (MRP), unrelated to the cost of supply, which is much higher. In the case of urea, the difference is reimbursed to the manufacturers as a subsidy on a ‘unit-specific’ basis. In the case of phosphatic and potassic (P&K) fertilisers, it fixes ‘uniform’ subsidy on a per-nutrient basis for all manufacturers and importers. The three basic factors impacting subsidy are MRP, per unit cost of supply and the...
More Comments are closed
Whether to resurrect LPG subsidy or not
The Govt should focus on reducing price (sans subsidy) by cutting import dependence, fostering competition by involving private entities and bringing it under GST The recent spurt in the price of LPG in the wake of Ukraine crisis has triggered a demand for resurrection of subsidy which the Narendra Modi government had stopped depositing in beneficiary’s accounts since June, 2020. Is the demand justified? By definition, subsidy on purchase of any given product is subvention or financial assistance provided by the state to a certain class of persons who cannot afford to pay the market-based or cost-plus price from their limited income. In case of LPG, the current price of a 14.2 kg cylinder is around Rs 2000 (in Delhi)....
More Comments are closed
The war’s impact on our fertiliser industry
Had there been a free market scenario, the industry would have come under serious strain. But that is not to be as fertilisers are under control The crisis in Ukraine following invasion by Russia has sent shock waves through out the world economy. In India, even as the steep rise in energy import bill will affect almost all sectors of the economy, the impact on fertilizers will be more pronounced. At the outset, let us capture a few relevant facts. Despite prognostications by successive governments during the last four decades or so that India would become self-reliant in fertilizer availability and putting in place policies aimed at achieving the goal, even today, the country remains preponderantly dependent on imports for...
More Comments are closed
Corporate governance — Sebi’s volte face
A reform measure cannot be held hostage to the whims and fancies of those who decide not to comply with the reform order Based on the recommendations of Uday Kotak committee on corporate governance (2018), the stock markets watchdog, Securities Exchange Board of India (SEBI) had asked listed companies to separate the positions of Chairperson and Managing Director (MD)/Chief Executive Officer (CEO). The requirement was mandatory. The companies were required to implement the order by April 2020. However, based on representations received from the industry, an additional two years was given for compliance. In April last year, SEBI chairman Ajay Tyagi goaded them to ensure that the April 2022 deadline is not missed. Now, that even this deadline is barely...
More Comments are closed
Rationalising the nation’s direct taxes
The Government should rationalise direct taxes to address anomalies between PIT and corporate tax at one level and capital gains tax at another Ever since, the commencement of its second term, Modi Government has showered benevolence on the corporate sector by giving relief in income tax but when it comes to personal income tax (PIT), it has not matched the expectations. On September 20, 2019, Finance Minister (FM) Nirmala Sitharaman had announced steep reduction in the rate of corporate tax for “new entities” incorporated from October 1, 2019 in the manufacturing sector and start production by March 31, 2023 from the existing 25 percent to 15 percent. Such companies won’t have to pay minimum alternate tax (MAT). Furthermore, the tax...
More Comments are closed
The Budget’s food subsidy conundrum
The subsidy currently covers 800 million and is meant for the poor. Heavily subsidised food is for the very poor. How can 2/3rd of Indians be very poor? In the Union Budget for 2022-23, the Modi government has allocated Rs 207,000 crore for food subsidy which is Rs 79,000 crore less than the actual expenditure of Rs 286,000 crore during 2021-22 as per the revised estimate (RE). Under the National Food Security Act (NFSA), 2013, the Union Government directs the Food Corporation of India (FCI) and other state agencies to procure food from the farmers at MSP (minimum support price) and organize its distribution to a mammoth population of 800 million people through an elaborate network of fair price shops...
More Comments are closed
Delinking seller from marketplace
In 2020, the Department of Consumer Affairs (DoCA) in the Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution had issued the Consumer Protection (e-commerce) Rules under Section 101 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. The rules lay down the conditions with which e-commerce firms should comply. Amongst others, these bar affiliated entities from selling on e-commerce platforms and restrict ‘flash sales’ (discounts or promotions they offer for a short duration) and disallow the seller from using the name or brand associated with that of the marketplace e-commerce entity for the promotion of goods. Within a year, the government has proposed certain amendments to these rules in the form of Consumer Protection (e-commerce) (Amendment) Rules, 2021. These amendments include restricting business-to-business, or...
More Comments are closed