A uniform tax rate of 15% (17.1% with add-ons) will, among other things, minimise tax litigation that arises largely due to multiple interpretations of a plethora of exemptions and deductions in tax legislation. Besides that, exemptions/incentives make the Indian law cumbersome to a point whereby it makes any prospective investor scary. A major factor affecting India’s ability to attract foreign investment for long has been the high rate of corporate tax. In 2018-19, the rate of tax on domestic companies was 30%. Including surcharge and cess, the total tax incidence is 34.9%. This made India an outlier as the corporate tax rate in other countries is much lower; for example, the US (21%), the OECD average (21.4%), China (25%), Vietnam...
More
Comments are closed
Category: The Financial Express
SC will have to solve the telco mess
A cue is available from the stance taken by SC itself in case of unpaid dues from public sector undertakings (PSUs) such as Gas Authority of India (GAIL), etc. The licence fee and SUC is charged as a percentage of service provider’s adjusted gross revenue (AGR)—8% and 3-5% respectively. During the last three years or so, the telecom industry has been enduring an unprecedented crisis, with most of the companies having huge debt in their books and not generating adequate cash flows for servicing the loans. The crisis was aggravated by an order of the Supreme Court (SC) on October 24, 2019, directing telecom firms to pay ‘unpaid’ dues towards licence fee and spectrum usage charges (SUC). The licence fee...
More
Comments are closed
Get ‘data exclusivity’ right
Agro-chemical majors won’t find India attractive for investment, as long as the regulator micro-manages even production decisions In the agrochemical sector, out of the total import of technical material or active ingredients that go into making end-use formulations, imports from China alone account for about 50%. Given China’s frequent changes in rules, targeting of MNCs, its deteriorating trade and investment relationship with the US, European countries and Japan, and questions over its role in spread of Covid-19 globally, hundreds of MNCs are planning to exit that country. They would either go back to their country of origin, or look for relocation destinations such as India. The Modi government has strongly indicated its intent to bring them here. In the agrochemical...
More
Comments are closed
What India should do when oil prices have crashed
With crude price low, the govt should think of moving completely to DBT for food, fertiliser and power. Crude oil plummeted to less than US$ 30 per barrel – drop of 50% over its level in the beginning of 2020. ————————————————————— Much before Covid 19 had assumed monstrous dimensions, the international crude oil market was already oversupplied. Then, OPEC and non-OPEC suppliers failed to reach an agreement as Russia refused to back even a moderate cut. In sync with its past behaviour under similar circumstances (1997, 2015), Saudi Arabia pumped additional supplies prompting tit-for-tat by Russia. As a result, crude oil plummeted to less than US $30 per barrel – drop of 50% over its level in the beginning of...
More
Comments are closed
Corona pushes discoms to the brink
Given the nature of the crisis, all concerned states should promptly release funds from their budgets to enable discoms to clear all outstanding dues This has meant the destruction of nearly 40% of the total electricity demand. ————————————————————- Even as corona has triggered widespread devastation, a major casualty is the power sector. Following the nation-wide lockdown announced by prime minister Narendra Modi on March 24—this was an absolute must given the hyper-contagious nature of the virus and an overarching need to preempt community transmission—most industries and businesses, including the Railways (passenger segment), have downed their shutters. This has meant the destruction of nearly 40% of the total electricity demand. All consumers, be it industries, shops and establishments, households, farmers, etc, fulfil their...
More
Comments are closed
Stop using fuel taxes as milch cow
High excise duty and VAT on fuel results in high inflation, higher subsidy payments on fertilisers, food, etc, and low international competitiveness of Indian goods. Centre is desperate to grab any opportunity available to garner additional revenue. Therefore, it has hiked the duty. ———————————————————————————————— In the wake of widespread destruction of demand triggered by Covid-19, failure of OPEC and non-OPEC suppliers to agree to a production cut, and the two front-line exporters from the respective groups viz. Saudi Arabia and Russia vying to capture the shrinking market, the price of crude oil has plunged to less than $30 per barrel. Leveraging this, in sync with its past practice of mopping up the oil bonanza, the Modi government has yet again...
More
Comments are closed
Fiscal slippage: The denial syndrome
Despite the govt window dressing numbers, it is expected to exceed FY20’s fiscal deficit target. Reforms are urgently needed to improve the Budget’s financial health. In the Union Budget for FY21, finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman revised the fiscal deficit (FD) for FY20 to 3.8% of GDP—up from the budget estimate (BE) of 3.3%. In absolute terms, the RE is Rs 7.66 lakh crore, against a BE of Rs 7 lakh crore. Sitharaman explained away the slippage by invoking the recommendations of the NK Singh committee on review of the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) Act, which permits breach of the target in case of “far reaching structural reforms with unanticipated fiscal implications”. The justification is untenable as, during the...
More
Comments are closed
Freebies: Why it is a road to fiscal disaster
Freebies provided by state governments need to consider the fiscal burden they will lead to, and must not be used to woo voters. AK has literally mesmerised Delhi voters by promising free/heavily subsidised electricity—24×7—and free water. —————————————————- In the just concluded elections in Delhi, the electorate has returned Arvind Kejriwal (AK) to the coveted position of chief minister with a thumping majority with Aam Aadmi Party (AAP), winning 62 out of a total of 70 assembly seats. AK has literally mesmerised Delhi voters by promising free/heavily subsidised electricity—24×7—and free water, besides several add-ons such as free bus ride for women, free Wi-Fi, full reimbursement of hospitalisation expenses in case of accident on an actuals basis, free testing and diagnostic services—if the facility is...
More
Comments are closed
Economic Survey 2020: Fudging food and fertiliser subsidy
Far from subsidy allocations coming down, as the Economic Survey had recommended, there is significant increase not reflected in govt balance sheets Economic Survey 2020: The food subsidy figure mentioned in the budget are reimbursements to FCI, and other state agencies engaged in similar operations on behalf of the Union. —————————————————————————————————– Economic Survey 2020: In the 2020 Economic Survey, released on January 31, the chief economic advisor (CEA), K Subramanian had recommended some reduction in food subsidy by limiting the scheme’s coverage, and increasing the issue price of foodgrains. One was, therefore, looking forward to announcement of a major reform in this regard in the Union Budget for FY21 presented by finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman the following day. While the speech...
More
Comments are closed
Why half-baked fertilizer reforms won’t deliver
If the government wants to restrict subsidised supply only to small and marginal farmers having landholding size <2 hectares, this will require two streams of supplies in the distribution channels viz. The Union government controls the maximum retail price (MRP) of urea at a low level, unrelated to the cost of production and distribution, which is much higher. —————————————————————————————————— Reportedly, the government is likely to fix nutrient-based subsidy (NBS) rate for urea before rolling out the direct cash transfer (DCT) of urea subsidy to farmers’ accounts. The subsidy, expressed as rupees per hectare, will be based on soil health, and size of landholding. The idea of NBS for urea is not new. It was recommended, in 2012, by a...
More
3 comments